Skip to main content
Robert Mays

Mays Chicago Restaurant List

NFL writer and host of The Athletic Football Show, Robert Mays' list of 170+ favorite Chicago restaurants. Updated through March 2026.

Source Google SheetOriginal post on XRobert's writing at The AthleticThe Athletic Football Show Podcast

172 restaurants

Chicago restaurants from Robert Mays' list. Use search and filters to narrow results; column headers open sort options.
3 Little Pigs"Untraditionally authentic Chinese"South LoopNot a favoriteGhost kitchen; pickup only — The char siu (BBQ pork) is the star. Fried rice with that, spam, and sausage is also a banger.2022
312 Fish MarketSushiChinatownSushi spot tucked into a large Asian grocery in Pilsen-Chinatown. Highly recommend.2023
5 RabanitosMexicanPilsenI love this place. Mexican standards, but ones I could eat every day. My favorite cochinita pibil I've had in Chicago.2023
AdalinaItalianGold CoastNot a favoriteOnly been for brunch.2022
Akahoshi RamenRamenLogan SquareIt's the best bowl of ramen I've had in Chicago, made by a guy who really cares about getting it right. If you can't get a reservation, just try walking in.2024/2025
Alegrias SeafoodMexican seafoodWicker ParkNot a favoriteNayarit-style seafood in a casual setting. Big, tasty portions of everything from camarones to stuffed lobster. Good spot for a casual group dinner.2023
AlineaFine dining- tasting menu $$$$Lincoln ParkNot a favorite3 Michelin star, fine-dining mecca. It's over-the-top in ways you appreciate, and unlike any dining experience I've had.2022
Alla VitaItalianWest LoopNot a favoriteBased on the ornate space and vibe, I had doubts. But the food was legit. Ricotta dumplings stood out. Satisfying chicken parm. We liked it.2022
Allez CafeBreakfast cafeLogan SquareNot a favoriteThe breakfast sandwich — bacon, steamed egg patty, onion aioli, jalapeno jam — is definitely worth trying if you're bouncing around the area.2024/2025
AmaruLatinWicker ParkNot a favoriteA local spot we've loved since it opened. We've ordered most of the (changing) menu, but the oxtail ravioli is a standout.2022
Andros TavernaGreekAndros TavernaNot a favoriteSolid, familiar Greek food in a beautiful, open space in Logan. Great patio meal in the summer.2022
AnelyaUkrainianBucktownNot a favoriteUkrainian spot in the old Wherewithall space in Avondale. A worthwhile trip, if only to try a cuisine I certainly wasn't familiar with prior to visiting.2024/2025
ApoloniaMediterranean ... ?Motor RowNot a favoriteSee for yourself. Just an excellent meal. The pastas — fiorentini with smoked tomato/sausage and bucatini with pickled eggplant and guanciale — stood out.2023
ArePa GeorgeColombianHumboldt ParkFamily-owned Colombian spot a block from me. The food is just delicious. Arepas are excellent, and some of the best empanadas I've ever had.2023
Asador BastianBasque steakhouseRiver NorthNot a favoriteIf you're looking for a splurge steakhouse dinner, this would be it. Elegant space, elevated options. The Galiciana steak with a bite of the Guindilla pepper it comes with will knock you on your ass.2024/2025
Asian Cuisine ExpressPan-Asian/al pastor tacosLittle VillageNot a favoritePosted about this place last year. The al pastor fried rice is more than just a novelty. It's fantastic, and worth the trip.2024/2025
AtelierTasting menuLincoln SquareNot a favoriteWent when they were in their old space, and I'll say it was hit or miss. Had a play on gazpacho and a fingerling hash that I remember enjoy, but a few of the courses didn't leave a mark.2024/2025
AtsumeruNordic-JapaneseWest TownNot a favoriteWe went right after they opened, but liked it. They're going for something different and interesting here. The chawanmushi with saffron and trout, and milk ice cream with pine stood out.2024/2025
AvecMediterraneanWest LoopNot a favoriteA Chicago food fixture still going strong 20 years later. Rock-solid Mediterranean spot.2022
Aztec Dave's CantinaMexicanHumboldt ParkNot a favoriteBurrito spot in Humboldt Park, have only gotten pick-up from there. The mole chicken burrito has become a go-to when I need a quick meal.2024/2025
Bayan KoFilipino-CubanRavenswoodFor me, one of the better tasting-menu deals in Chicago. $129 for 6 courses of refined Filipino and Cuban classics. The arroz caldo knocked me on my ass.2024/2025
Best Intentions"A fancy cocktail bar"Logan SquareTechnically a bar (and the only one here), but my favorite local haunt and a spot with *very* good bar food. The burger is everything I need and want from a burger.2024/2025
Birrieria Estilo JaliscoMexicanBucktownNot a favoriteHole in the wall birria spot. Get a pound of birria, a cup of consomme, and a container of warm tortillas. You'll leave satisfied.2023
Birrieria ZaragozaTacos (goat birria)Archer HeightsGet a big bowl of goat birria in consomme and go to town. One of the most satisfying meals in the city. 2nd location in Uptown just opened.2022
BLVD SteakhouseSteakhouseWest LoopNot a favoriteOnly went for brunch, but the menu/decor set up for fairly typical West Loop steakhouse fare.2024/2025
Bocadillo MarketSpanish sandwichesWest TownNot a favoriteNew Spanish sandwich spot that I'm eager to try again. Actually got the tempura squash by mistake and was kinda floored by how good it was?2024/2025
BoeufhausGerman steakhouseWest TownNot a favoriteGreat vibe, great service, in a cozy space. Hearty and comforting cooking that's still interesting. Had short rib beignets, buttered turnips, and a killer duck breast.2024/2025
BokaContemporary AmericanLincoln ParkHas become one of my quickest Chicago recommendations. Just damn good Michelin-starred seasonal cooking in a beautiful space with fantastic service. Great date spot.2024/2025
Boonie's FilipinoFilipinoNorth CenterTop-5 meal of 2023. We ordered the whole menu. The sisig — sizzling pork hash — stole the show, but every single dish is worth getting. Go here.2023
BraseroWood-fired LatinWest TownMy favorite Latin-inspired steak place to open up recently. The menu is just more varied and interesting, and you can still get a great steak. Great spot for a big group.2024/2025
Bungalow by MiddlebrowWood-fired pizzaLogan SquareTavern Tuesdays is the move. Cracker-thin sourdough pizza cut into bite-size squares, with one crazy special – only on Tuesday. A mainstay for us.2022
Calumet FisheriesSmoked fishSouth DeeringNot a favoriteSmall takeout-only place near the Indiana border off 90. Grab some on the way home from a trip. Black cod and garlic-pepper salmon. (Temp. closed)2022
CariñoMexican tasting menuUptownMichelin-starred tasting menu featuring inventive, elevated takes on Mexican classics. For a celebration meal, it's on a short list of places I'd recommend.2024/2025
Carniceria MaribelTacosPilsenNot a favoriteThe taco counter is in the back. The lomo de res is one of my favorite tacos in the entire city.2024/2025
Casa YariPuerto RicanLogan SquareNot a favoriteReally good Puerto Rican breakfast spot specializing in mofongos — a bowl of cut up and fried plantains filled and covered with all sorts of stuff2022
Cellar Door ProvisionsBistroLogan SquareNot a favoriteBistro known for their wines, with a constantly changing, seasonal Mediterranean menu. Great date night/dinner spot.2022
Chef's SpecialChineseBucktownNot a favoriteCocktail bar with American-Chinese favorites like lo mein, fried rice. The eggplant with spicy lamb sausage was particularly good.2023
Coach HouseIndian tasting menuWicker ParkNot a favoriteTasting menu in the back of Zubair Mohajir's more casual spot, Lilac Tiger. The menu we tried in 2024 eventually spawned Mirra, the new concept in Bucktown.2024/2025
Community Tavern"Midwestern ingredients with pan-Asian influences"Portage ParkTop 5 meal of 2023. Some Asian influence, but hard to explain. Short rib dumplings. A great burger. Kimchi cheddar fries. Crazy pork chop. Just go.2023
Creepie'sBistroWest LoopIt's just my kind of restaurant. The food is out there in the best way. Everything has surprising a twist of texture or flavor. I can't wait to go back. And Anna Posey makes the best desserts in Chicago.2024/2025
D'AmatosSandwichesWest TownNot a favoriteClassic Chicago bakery that's a worthwhile stop for a weekday lunhc.2024/2025
DaisiesPastaLogan SquareA beautiful expression of local ingredients channeled mostly through pasta. A spot I'd recommend to anyone and everyone.2022
Dear MargaretFrenchLincoln ParkNot a favoriteClassic French feel expressed through Midwestern ingredients.2023
DemeraEthiopianUptownTraditional Ethiopian in a cozy space. I loved my visit here. A great group dinner spot if you're looking for something different.2022
Diana'sPuerto Rican sandwichesHumboldt ParkNot a favoriteCLOSED2024/2025
Dolo RestaurantDim sumChinatownNot a favoriteDim sum to order, just off the main drag in Chinatown.2022
Don Pedro CarnitasMexicanPilsenNot a favoriteCarnitas by the pound with different options of pork cuts. Great bang for your buck, and one of the only spots like this left on 18th.2024/2025
Duck InnGastropubBridgeportThe moment we left, I was saying that I couldn't wait to go back. "Gastropub" fits but doesn't do it justice. Just comforting and craveable dishes that keep you coming back for more of it.2024/2025
Duck SelTasting menuUptownNot a favoriteTasting menu for 20 (?) served in an Uptown apartment. For real. Silly, fun, different. Read up and see if it's for you.2023
Dusek'sWood-fired tasting menuPilsenNot a favoriteCLOSED2023
EaThaiThaiAvondaleNot a favoriteOur local Thai takeout spot. Duck wontons and curry puffs are great. Reliable version of Thai classics.2023
El CheArgentinianWest LoopNot a favoriteMamixmilist vibe for a maximlist group meal. Got the parillada with steak, chorizo, and morcilla AND the mar de plata. But favorite thing might've been the sweetbreads with giardiniera.2024/2025
El CubanitoCubanLogan SquareNot a favoriteSpot on Pulaski right near The Athletic Show studios that just makes a very good Cuban sandwich.2024/2025
El HabaneroMexicanLogan SquareNot a favoriteFamily-owned Mexican spot that specializes in pambazos — similar to a torta, but with bread dipped in a red guajillo sauce and lightly fried. YEAH.2023
ElskeModern ScandinavianWest LoopJust great, inventive food done well. Michelin-starred kitchen in my favorite restaurant space in Chicago. A 2023 fav. Get the sunflower seed parfait with bee pollen2023
EsmeRotating tasting menuLincoln ParkA Michelin-star tasting menu that turns over each quarter, redesigned in connection with the work of a local artist. Worth a trip for a special occasion.2023
Evette'sLebanese/MexicanLincoln ParkNot a favoriteThe type of place where you can get shawarma fries and a gyro taco. Good for a quick lunch. You can also pick up.2023
FeldTasting menuUkrainian VillageMichelin-starred testing menu with more than 25 courses, focusing on relationships with farmers and purveyors. Thoughtfully curated, engaging experience.2024/2025
FireWood-fired tasting menuFulton MarketNot a favoriteCLOSED2024/2025
GalitMiddle EasternLincoln Park4-course prix fixe menu that might be my favorite meal in the city. Every coal-fire main course rocks.2022
Gene and Jude'sHot dogsRiver Grove, ILNot a favoriteClassic for a reason. The type of place that makes a Chicago hot dog stand worth being romantic about.2024/2025
GiantNew AmericanLogan SquareAnother favorite of ours. Menu is hard to pin down. Just get everything. The saffron tagliatelle with crab was a highlight last time.2022
Goree CuisineSenegaleseKenwoodNot a favoriteAnother great Senegalese option on the south side. The mafe here — a peanut stew with lamb — was probably my favorite2023
Haisous Vietnamese KitchenVietnamesePilsenOne of the best meals I had in 2023. The Bún Chả Hanoi and crab fried rice stand out, but order as many things as you can.2023
HermosaCambodianHermosaNot a favoriteWe did their Family Meal. A BYOB private dining experience for up to 11. Something fun and different for a group of food-loving friends.2023
Il CarciofoItalianFulton MarketNot a favoriteJoe Flamm's crowd-pleaser Roman spot, featuring a variety of pizzas and pastas. The mortadella panino and basil gnocchi special were standouts.2024/2025
Immm Rice and BeyondThaiUptownNot a favoriteThai street food with an extensive menu. Great lunch special — 3 items with rice/noodles for $12.502022
IndienneIndian tasting menuRiver NorthRecently earned a Michelin star. Some of the most creative dishes we ate all year.Unknown
IstmoOaxacanWrigleyvilleNot a favoriteStopped in shortly after they opened and were just serving brunch. Excited to come back for dinner. In terms of vibe, felt very much like the restaurants we visited in Oaxaca.2024/2025
JeongKorean tasting menuWest TownNot a favoriteSmall, elegant space that's worthy of a special occasion. Pricey, but the food is very good.2022
Jibaritos y MasPuerto RicanLogan SquareNot a favoriteJibaritos are a uniquely Chicagoan creation. A sandwich with two flattened, fried plantains as bread. If that sounds appealing, you're right.2022
John's Food and WineModern AmericanLincoln ParkNot a favoriteReally good seasonal American dishes (pan-roasted trout with a bean ragout, beef fat fries, squid-ink chiferri with crab) with counter ordering; good group spot2024/2025
John's PizzeriaTavern-style pizzaLogan SquareNot a favoriteCLOSED2022
JP GrazianoSub shopWest LoopNot a favoriteClassic Chicago sandwich place that deserves the acclaim. A Mr. G and a muffaleta from here will make your day.2024/2025
KasamaFilipinoUkrainian VillageAmerica's only Michelin-starred Filipino restaurant. Tasting menu experience unlike any I've ever had.2022
Khmai Cambodian Fine DiningCambodianRogers ParkNot a favoriteWe did the tasting menu, which is rotating based on a different region in Cambodia. At $100 for 8 courses, it's a way to try a bunch of flavors that were new to us and might be to you.2024/2025
Kie Gol LaneeOaxacanUptownNot a favoriteTraditional Oaxacan food with a new Logan Square location. Place to try a tlayuda, which is a large, crispy tortilla topped with beans, cheese, cabbage, etc.2024/2025
KumikoJapanese dining barWest LoopWarm, inviting space with excellent bar eats and a renown drink menu — including N/A2022
Kyoten Next DoorOmakaseLogan SquareThe ideal omakase experience for me. 15 courses of straight nigiri with perfectly seasoned rice in a beautiful setting. Great special occasion spot.2023
La BirrerriaBirria tacosHermosaNot a favoriteNo-frills birria taco spot in Hermosa.2024/2025
La BombaPuerto RicanLogan SquareNot a favoriteCasual local Puerto Rican spot serving the classics.2024/2025
La Chaparrita TaqueriaTacosLittle VillageFavorite taco place in Chicago. By a lot. Housed in a Mexican grocery store in Little Village. Cabeza, campechano are highlights.Unknown
LardonDeli/sandwichesLogan SquareNot a favoriteIn-house charcuterie program serving up some great sandwiches. Perfect lunch spot.2022
Lilac TigerSouth AsianWicker ParkNot a favoriteDelicious and comforting South Asian street food. Tandoori honey chicken sandwich and duck fried rice are bangers.2023
Little Bad WolfGastropub/bar foodAndersonvilleNot a favoriteBar known for its burger, and the burger is great. The red onion mayo makes it.2023
Loaf LoungeBakeryAvondaleNot a favoritePastries and breakfast sandwiches2023
Lonesome RoseTex-MexLogan SquareNot a favoriteStill my favorite nachos. Cheese sauce, pickled onions and banana peppers, black beans, your protein of choice. A mainstay for me on couch-rot day.2024/2025
Los TepalcatesTacosRoscoe VillageCasual sit-down Mexican spot with an excellent variety of options. Had a lomo, shrimp with grilled peppers, cochinita pibil, plus the jugo de carne. Perfect for weekend lunch.2024/2025
Lucidos TacosTacosLittle VillageIn the discusson for best al pastor I've had in Chicago. The toro taco — pastor and a spicy chorizo — was also fantastic.2024/2025
Lula CafeNew AmericanLogan SquareA brunch staple and Chicago institution. Seemingly simple, seasonal cooking that's familiar yet exciting. Get the specials!2022
LyraGreekFulton MarketNot a favoriteA Greek restaurant that sort of turns into a club, I guess? I do not understand this place.2022
Mano a ManoItalianLogan SquareNot a favoritePasta place that's the sister restaurant to Andros Taverna next door. Type of down-the-middle spot that's perfect to bring your parents (which we have).2024/2025
Mariscos San PedroMexican seafoodPilsenNot a favoriteA worthwhile homage to the buzziest mariscos places in Mexico City. A place with Instagram-worthy aguachiles and an octopus-stuffed Sonoran dog.2024/2025
Mas Alla Del SolMexicanEdgewaterNot a favoriteTakes on traditional Mexican staples. Pollo en mole. Carne asada. Chile relleno.2022
Maxwells TradingAsian-influenced contemporary AmericanWest LoopDon't think there's a better spot for a group dinner in right now. Hard place to explain, but everything is great. There's a menu section called "griddle bread and dunks." Sweet potato is unbelievable.2024/2025
Mi Tocaya AntojeríaMexicanLogan SquareOne of my favorite restaurants in Chicago. Just thinking the food here makes me smile. Superb takes on Mexican staples.2022
Mindy's BakeryBakeryWicker ParkWe love Mindy's. They go great savory pastries, but sweet stuff is great too. She did the desserts for our wedding, so we're a little biased. Expect a line.2023
Ming Hin CuisineChineseChinatownNot a favoriteClassic Cantonese meal good for big groups.Unknown
MirraIndian-MexicanBucktownNot a favoriteIndian-Mexican spot that I actually first tried when it was a tasting concept at Coach House. It's a fun meal in a beautiful space. The lamb barbacoa biryani is a showstopper.2024/2025
Mister TigerKoreanWest TownCool spot for a group dinner. Lot of big flavors. The monkfish was in a spicy gochugang sauce that was particulary memorable, and thought the Korean mainstays were very good.2024/2025
Monster RamenRamenLogan SquareNot a favoriteSpecializes in gyukotsu-style (a beef broth) with noodles made in house. The Monster comes with wagyu and beef jam. Maybe the richest ramen I've ever had.2023
MonteverdePastaWest LoopA decade after opening and 6 years after winning a James Beard, still hard to get a reservation. There's a reason why. Every pasta will kick your teeth in.2023
NaduIndianLincoln ParkNot a favoriteNewer regional Indian spot from the folks behind Indienne. Enjoyed everything we had, but was honestly surprised at all the hype around it.2024/2025
Nellie'sPuerto Rican breakfastHumboldt ParkNot a favoriteBreakfast spot that's great on a winter day. The avena de coco is a delicious coconut oatmeal. Also try the tortilla boricua — essentially an omelette with plantains.2023
NextRotating tasting menuFulton MarketThe Alinea group's rotating concept. We went twice this year – for the Paris 1906 and Tuscany menus. Awesome place for a special occasion.2023
Nhu LanBahn MiLincoln SquareNot a favoriteEverything I want in a bahn mi, but I'm not an expert. Have only had the roasted pork and lemongrass chicken. It's worth a quick drive if you're craving one.2024/2025
Novel Pizza CafeTavern-style pizzaPilsenThe longanisa and giardiniera is maybe my favorite tavern-style pizza in town. And you can just walk in, order it, and enjoy it. This place deserves more love.2024/2025
ObelixFrenchRiver NorthNot a favoriteThey are GOING FOR IT here. There's a duck *section* of the menu that includes a foie gras macaron and a foie gras taco. You have to respect it.2023
OliversSupper ClubSouth LoopNot a favoriteThe trout-roe oysers, toast royale (beef-fat grilled sourdough with carmelized shallot butter — YEAH), and half-chicken is a fantastic night out for two.2024/2025
Omarcito's Latin CafePan-Latin sandwichesLogan SquareNot a favoriteAwesome sandwiches, jibaritos, and empanadas on a patio in the west end of Logan. Perfect for lunch at the end of a summertime walk.2024/2025
OrioleFine dining- tasting menu $$$$West Loop2 Michelin star tasting menu. The go-big dinner spot I'd most recommend in Chicago. The space and the food are seriously stunning.2022
Osteria LangheItalianLogan SquareNot a favoriteRegional cuisine from northwest Italy. A traditional, familiar Italian experience.2022
OutputSports barWest TownNot a favoriteKnown for their wings. I'm no wing connoisseur, but thought they were pretty damn good. Variety of flavors, traditional Buffalo was great, good size, nice and crispy. Good pregame option near UC.2024/2025
ParachuteKoreanAvondaleNot a favoriteWell regarded Korean spot. Been a couple times, and to be honest — haven't enjoyed it as much as others seem to.2022
Pequod'sPizzaLincoln parkNot a favoriteThe Chicago deep dish place worth trying when you're in town. Crispy, caramelized cheese. Every time I go with visitors, I'm reminded of why it's adored.2023
Perilla fareKoreanWest LoopNot a favoriteI think we ate 80 percent of the menu last time we went here with another couple. Korean BBQ spot that's good for groups.2024/2025
Petite EdithFrenchRiver NorthNot a favoriteBistro from the chef at Esme. French staples with some twists. Enjoyed everything, weren't blown away by anything. Big, beautiful bar that invites neighborhood regulars.Unknown
Pho VietVietnameseUptownNot a favoriteTraditional Vietnamese spot at Broadway and Argyle. Grab a bowl of pho on a cold day. The staff was overtly kind when I stopped in.2022
Pizza MattaPizzaLogan SquareNot a favoriteTakeout pizza spot from the folks who run Giant. Their new tavern style is addictive. Great ingredients. Also like the pistachio pesto-marinara combo sauce.2023, 2024/2025
Pizza'miciTavern-style pizzaWest TownNot a favoriteThe hot new tavern-style spot in town. Reservations are tough, but the pizza is delicious. Server recommended hot honey and jalapeño, and it didn't disappoint;2024/2025
PompetteWine bar/bistroBucktownNot a favoriteNeighborhood wine bar and cafe with a warm vibe and a menu/selection well suited to a dinner with a small group of friends.2024/2025
Ponce RestaurantPuerto RicanHermosaNot a favoriteLocal spot with Puerto Rican staples. The alcapurria (a banana dumpling filled with pork) was an outstanding bite.2023
ProxiHard-to-pin-down small platesWest LoopNot a favoriteLot going on. Asian flavors, Indian influences. Want to go back. Recall it being good in the moment but not all that memorable.2022
QXY DumplingsChinese- dumplingsChinatownMy brother and I ordered about 60 dumplings. The lamb-coriander and shrimp-pork-leek stood out, but everything was great. Excellent service too.2023
Ramen SanRamenWest LoopNot a favorite"Ramen spot in the West Loop" about sums it up.2022
Red Hot RanchBurgers/hot dogsLogan SquareNot a favoriteClassic chicago spot for griddled smashburgers and dogs. The double cheeseburger and fries is maybe the best way to eat for under 10 bucks in the city.2024/2025
Rica Arepa VenezuelaVenezuelanVenezuelanNot a favoriteArepas as big as your head.2022
RoisterCasual New AmericanFulton MarketNot a favoriteCLOSED2022
RoohProgressive IndianWest LoopNot a favoriteClassic Indian flavors presented via modern techniques. A worthwhile dinner night spot.2022
Rose MaryItalian/Croatian — Adriatic "drinking food"Fulton MarketLively space and a menu filled with shareable pastas, risottos, and seafood. Ideal spot for a fun group dinner.2022
Rubi's on 18thTacosPilsenNot a favoriteExcellent, hefty tacos from the brick-and-mortar location of a longtime Pilsen taco stand. Only open til 6 pm from Thursday-Sunday.2022
S.K.Y.Contemporary, I guessPilsenNot a favoriteSimilar to his other spot, Apolonia, it's hard to pin down. But the food is great. The cornbread madeleines were a memorable bit. Lobster dumplings too.2023
Santa Masa TamaleriaMexicanPortage ParkCounter-service spot that's mostly open for breakfast and lunch. The traditional options on the menu are great, but get the tamal of the month too. They serve a great green pozole on the weekend too.2024/2025
Second GenerationCLOSEDLogan SquareNot a favoriteCLOSED2023
Seoul StickKorean street foodWicker ParkNot a favoriteKorean corn dog spot with a bunch of whacky options and flavors.2024/2025
Serai MalaysianMalaysianLincoln ParkNot a favoriteWhen they were in Logan, Serai had become a regular takeout spot. They have a variety of Asian pan-fried noodle dishes that are worth trying if you want something different.2024/2025
Smash JibaritoBurger/Puerto RicanHumboldt ParkNot a favoriteDoes a smash burger on a fried plantain sound good to you? It should. Cool concept that really delivers. Even thinking about it right now makes we want one. Go for lunch if you're in Humboldt.2024/2025
SmythFine dining- tasting menu $$$$West LoopNot a favoriteJust awarded a 3rd Michelin star. Gorgeous space, thoughtful food, upscale but welcoming. A worthwhile splurge if you're looking for one.2022
Soul and SmokeBarbecueAvondaleNot a favoriteBBQ and soul food options that are just asking you to put together a feast. I'm not NOT gonna get the smoked chicken gumbo to go with my brisket.2024/2025
SouléSouthernUkrainian VillageNot a favoriteHas since moved locations.2022
Spice RoomIndianLogan SquareNot a favoriteDependable neighborhood Indian spot that's easy for pick-up. Has fallen out of the rotation in favor of other options.2024/2025
Spinning J BakeryBakery/piesHumboldt ParkNot a favoriteOld-school setting with great breakfast sandwiches and a pie case filled with exciting twists on the classics. Have brought the hibiscus-key lime home more than once.2024/2025
Strings Ramen ShopRamenLakeviewNot a favoriteLakeview location of a solid local Ramen chain.2023
SueñosMexicanWest LoopNot a favoriteCLOSED2022
Sultan's MarketMiddle EasternWicker ParkCasual Shawarma spot that shouldn't have taken me this long to try. I was blown away by the chicken AND lamb. Perfect lunch-takeout spot on the go.2023
SuperkhanaIndianLogan SquareNot a favoriteBest described as Indian fusion. Butter chicken calzone. Naan pizzas with paneer. Lamb bolognese. The tamarind dal was the standout.2023
Sushi Suite 202SushiLincoln ParkNot a favoriteOmakase in a suite at the Hotel Lincoln. Cool concept, fun to try once. Would go with other similarly $ omakase if I had to pick.2022
Table, Donkey and StickSeasonal neighborhood innLogan SquareEmbarrassed that it took years to try this place. I still think about that potato galette with bits of shortbread. Perfect date night spot for charcurterie and a glass of wine.2024/2025
Taco El JaliscienseMexicanHumboldt ParkNot a favoriteRock-solid taco spot at Grand and Chicago great for a quick lunch.2024/2025
Tacos de Canasta RossyTacosHermosaNot a favorite"Basket tacos" served out of a pizza place/bar in Hermosa. Limited hours, mostly on the weekend.2023
Tacos HerederoTacosHumboldt ParkNot a favoriteLocal taco spot around the corner. The chile relleno taco was very good.2023
TacotlanTacos (beef birria)HermosaNot a favoriteYour classic quesabirria tacos, with all the cheese and fat-soaked tortillas you could want.2022
Taqueria ChingonTacosBucktownNot a favoriteThe tacos here are just damn good. No way around it. Al pastor and duck carnitas hit every time. Their Monday omakase experience is also very cool.2023
Taqueria El MezquiteMexicanPilsenNot a favoriteA reminder of how many quality taco places are just hiding all over Chicago. Nice outdoor patio when the weather cooperates.2023
Taqueria La ZacatecanaTacosAvondaleCounter-service taco place with some of the best carne asada tacos I've had in some time.2024/2025
Tempesta MarketSandwichesWest TownNot a favoriteThere are few things more beautiful than a really good sandwich. I remember trying the Italian here and being swept up in how good the goddamn tomato was. A favorite of the TAFS office.2024/2025
ThattuIndianAvondaleMy favorite Chicago meal of 2023. Coastal Indian fare from Kerala. Ordered the whole menu. The pork chop and chicken biryani were insane.2023
TriBecca's Sandwich ShopSandwichesAvondaleNot a favoriteGood pickup spot if you're looking for a very good, quick sandwich. Their Cubano is slathered in chipotle aioli and hits the spot every time.2023
TrinoLatin steakhouseWest LoopNot a favoriteHad enjoyed Sueños when it was in the Soho House, and it's probably telling that the crab tostada was my favorite thing at this meal. Just wasn't all that exciting for what it costs.2024/2025
Trivoli TavernSteak/seafoodWest LoopNot a favoriteVery much a Hogsalt operation (the restaurant group). Space is A LOT, food was solid if all over the place. But the desserts are excellent. Butterfinger pie.2023
Tuk Tuk ThaiThaiWicker ParkNot a favoriteTried the new location in Wicker Park. Heaping portions of Thai street food options. Enjoyed just about everything we tried. Good for a group meal.2024/2025
UmamicueChinese-Vietnamese BBQLogan SquareNot a favoriteBBQ spot served out of Spilt Milk bar in Logan. Unbelievable brisket. And you can get any of the meats in a banh mi.2023
Uncle Mike's PlaceFilipino breakfastWest TownNot a favoriteCome here for breakfast. Longanisa sausage or tocino pork served with garlic rice and eggs.2023
UnionBar/New AmericanLogan SquareNot a favoriteWell done gastropub fare, but you're coming here for the bar. A perfect spot to enjoy some beers (N/A too!) and a few hours of conversation.2023
VajraIndianWicker ParkNot a favoriteHave transitioned to takeout-only from their Wicker Park space. Might be my favorite takeout/delivery Indian spot in our area.2024/2025
ValhallaTasting menuWicker ParkNot a favoriteWent for Casey's birthday and loved it. Memorable, big flavors in just about every course. Doesn't hold back in a way I appreciated. Good option for a celebratory meal.2024/2025
VirtueSouthernHyde ParkSouthern classics done incredibly well. Best mac and cheese I've eaten. Their blackened catfish was a favorite bite of 2022.2022
Vito and Nick'sTavern-style pizzaAshburnFamous tavern-style pizza place. Cracker-thin crust. Sauce with some zip. Cash only. In a bar. Doesn't get more Chicago than this.2022
VoidQuirky ItalianAvondaleUnlike any other place I've been to in Chicago. Quirky and weird without trying TOO hard. The spaghetti uh-ohs are a cute idea, but it also tastes fucking great. Had a killer corn pasta too.2024/2025
WherewithallFour course, rotating menuAvondaleNot a favoriteCLOSED2022
Yaba'sMiddle EasternLogan SquareNot a favoriteMiddle Eastern takeout spot in the back of a grocery. Might be the best falafel I've ever had.2023
Yassa African RestaurantSenegaleseBronzevilleWas my first time trying Senegalese food and loved it. Big, exciting flavors across the board. The Thiou curry was the highlight.2022